Why Did Jesus Forgive Peter and Not Judas?

Author Ryan Cole

Posted Jan 23, 2023

Reads 69

Crucifix on Top of Bible

Jesus Christ is revered as a symbol of mercy, but He still chose to be selective in His show of forgiveness. One example of this selectiveness was the treatment of two of His disciples, Peter and Judas Iscariot. Both had been trusted with the same duties and were even present during Jesus’s Last Supper. But when the two failed to uphold their responsibilities, Jesus chose to forgive Peter but to leave Judas unpardoned. Why?

The first possible explanation has to do with the type of offense that each man committed. Peter denied knowing Jesus three times while Judas actively betrayed him by delivering him into the Captain’s hands under authority from the High Priest. Although both had sinned, Judas’s offense was much more calculated and fundamentally left no room for redemption. Meanwhile, Peter’s denial can be viewed as a result of fear and shock in the moment he realized that Jesus was going to be arrested and crucified. This arguably provides some space for repentance, although it was made after his initial mistake nonetheless.

The second explanation could have to do with the differential attitude they each expressed in response to their mistake: humility versus prideful dominance. After his third denial Peter went outside with tears streaming down his eyes, embodying genuine repentance over his failure; meanwhile Judas ignored Jesus' reprimand and continued bargaining with the high priest for his own selfish financial gain even after being told that God’s plan must take precedence over any individual plans or purposes. Showing little remorse for what he had done, it could be argued that Judas lacked repentance which has long been a necessary ingredient for receiving forgiveness from God - this idea even appears in scripture when Paul writes that “Godly sorrow brings repentance that leads no regrets...” (2 Corinthians 7:10).

In summary, Jesus may have chosen to forgive Peter for various reasons - among them an identifiable relationship between Peter's sin and possible repentance - which could explain why He showed mercy whereas He withheld his personal favor from Judas Iscariot who showed no sign of having received conviction or humility whatsoever towards correcting his wrong doing against God and/or humanity at large.

What prompted Jesus to forgive Peter and not Judas?

Jesus’ mercy and forgiveness was incredibly apparent when He looked upon Peter with compassion and showed mercy on Judas despite the treachery of his latter act. Differentiating between the two in this very situation brings forth the understanding of what made Jesus decide to forgive Peter, and what ultimately led to Judas’ cruel fate.

Peter, who served faithfully and unyieldingly under Jesus’ discerning eye, was credited with holding a great amount of personal value in the eyes of Jesus because of his unconditional devotion. Peter was able to fully understand who Jesus was—the Son of God—yet chose to accept him despite his status as a mere carpenter in societal terms. Thus, when Peter denied such acceptance three times before His crucifixion, Jesus still found a way to forgive him due to his unwavering loyalty demonstrated throughout their time together up until that point.

In comparison, Judas had no personal value nor loyalty with regards to Jesus. Even after being entrusted with caring for the finances of Jesus’ ministry and mission work, Judas still resorted back to siding with those who sought out only selfish and evil motives. To reciprocate such loyalty as an apostle for Christ himself showed an utter lack thereof for what He stood for—hence why he was deemed not worthy of such forgiveness from Jesus upon revealing himself as the one who had betrayed him.

Ultimately speaking, it can be said that Peter received Jesus’ forgiveness because he demonstrated sincere faithfulness towards Him through both word and action; whereas Judas did not display any mannerism or sentimentality whatsoever making his misdeed unforgivable according to Christ’s standards.

Why did Jesus choose to forgive Peter and not Judas?

Jesus choosing to forgive Peter more openly than Judas was a direct reflection of the different characteristics both men possessed. Peter is known as the apostle of belief, while Judas possessed traits of greed, vulnerability and an eagerness to cast aside his relationship with Jesus. It was meant to serve as a message of unconditional love and mercy from Jesus, displaying that everyone could be given a chance at redemption no matter what wrongs they have done in life.

Throughout their journeys with Jesus, Peter remained committed and loyal; even when he doubted Jesus’ path for him at times, he stayed the course and never let the bond between them break. Conversely, Judas’ link with him began fading away shortly after Jesus started paving his way for a mission of forgiveness. In essence, it seemed that Judas had not fully accepted the teachings of faith which left little room for forgiveness from Jesus as he was unable to make amends for his wrongs.

Ultimately, Jesus chose to forgive Peter out of love while teaching others an important lesson: that there's always hope when it comes to having faith in him and seeking his mercy. As long as one believes in him, repenting of past sins can lead to great blessings. He is merciful and forgiving but also abides by cosmic principles that require us to make sincere efforts towards self-betterment for us to receive His grace!

How did Jesus respond differently toward Peter and Judas?

within the context of Christianity.

Jesus’ relationship with his two disciples, Peter and Judas, serves as a lesson of how to show forgiveness and understanding through a wide range of responses.

As an example, Jesus had plans to restore Peter despite his threefold denial. After Peter’s repentance and atonement, Jesus graciously welcomed him back as one of his beloved disciples and even gave him the title “Rock” (Matt 16:18). Additionally, when Peter tried to dissuade Jesus from accepting martyrdom one week before Easter, Jesus met his resistance with patience and grace (Mk 8:32-33).

When it comes to Judas Iscariot, who betrayed Jesus for money, the response was entirely different. Despite never publicly forgiving Judas for his crime and trauma he inflicted on himself by hanging himself in shame, Jesus issued him warning words that imply an implicit hope in His mercy (Mt 26:24). Moreover, when the large crowd that intended to stone the adulteress caught in adultery threatened to judge her according to Mosaic law, instead of throwing stones with them or leaving her condemned without any absolution; He showed mercy by telling them “Let anyone among you who is without sin be the first to throw a stone” (John 8:7).

In this way, Jesus displayed both sternness and mercy towards His two disciples. Ultimately He showed that our human shortcomings can be forgiven if we are just willing to receive it.

What lessons can be learned from Jesus' forgiveness of Peter and not Judas?

Forgiveness is a cornerstone of Christian teaching and the lessons that Jesus of Nazareth taught through his example are invaluable. His willingness to forgive when faced with immense personal pain and hurt doesn’t go unnoticed. In particular, his instance of forgiving Peter but not Judas deeply resonates and teaches us lessons about guilt, repentance, justice and mercy.

The lack of mercy for Judas is often difficult for people to accept because it goes against modern conceptions around the importance of forgiveness. However, Jesus’ actions were in pursuit of higher values that demand action beyond the binary options presented by a world that often operates only within black and white terms. While Jesus chose not to forgive Judas for his betrayal, he did offer him compassion which offers another lesson; we don’t need to forgive someone in order to have compassion for them or to recognize their wrongdoings as wrong.

Moreover, one can argue that Jesus’ mercy towards Peter highlights an important lesson regarding guilt being inherent when we make mistakes. Perhaps it serves as a source of comfort in recognizing the fact that while we may make grave errors ours accidents, our ultimate worth isn’t something that should be completely judged by them. We have the opportunity to learn from our mistakes, repent and be forgiven -- no matter how severe the mistake may be.

Though this passage in Biblical verse has been analyzed countless times throughout history -- its profound lessons remain as true today as ever before; mistakes should cause us pause for reflection and repenting for our wrongdoings demonstrates remorse that can help lead us towards being forgiven by those impacted by our actions or from ourselves. Both Jesus’ inability to overlook yet still find compassion for his disciple Judas and his mercy extended to Peter after converting serve as meaningful reminders regarding forgiveness even when justice demands retribution.

How might Jesus' forgiveness of Peter differ from his response to Judas?

The story of Jesus forgiving Peter and then responding differently to Judas stirs an important question: How might Jesus’ forgiveness of Peter differ from his response to Judas?

It’s widely accepted that Jesus gives us second chances, allowing us to repent and grow closer in our relationship with Him. Interestingly enough, this same motive is evident in the story of Peter and Judas: both had denied Christ yet Jesus extended forgiveness towards one of them – Peter. This kind of extensive mercy is only possible through Christ’s loving-kindness.

Still, some argue that a major difference between the two can be found in the person’s attitude and willingness towards God. Specifically, Peter repented from his blasphemy and humbly asked for forgiveness even before Jesus told him “Your faith has saved you.” On the other hand, Judas did not change his attitude - he rejected God and felt remorse for what he had done but seemingly refused to admit it himself – ultimately hanging himself after his betrayal.

One difference between their responses could then be broken down into an attitude towards repentance; Judas refused it altogether while Peter welcomed it with open arms. It's interesting to take note that although both stories ended sadly, because of the contrasting responses one still managed to have hope while the other perished without finding any reconciliation with Christ.

Ryan Cole

Ryan Cole

Writer at Nahf

View Ryan's Profile

Ryan Cole is a blogger with a passion for writing about all things tech. He has been working in the industry for over 10 years and has gained extensive knowledge and experience along the way. Ryan loves to research and stay up-to-date on the latest trends, gadgets, and software.

View Ryan's Profile